Avijit Roy and His Legacy: Guest Post by Jahed Ahmed
March 12, 2015
Note: This is a guest post by Jahed Ahmed, a co-founder of the Mukto-mona website and a friend of Avijit Roy. Dr. Roy was killed on February 26, 2015. This article will run in the June/July issue of the Center for Inquiry’s magazine, Free Inquiry.
Thanks to the Internet, Avijit Roy is now more famous than ever. Several Islamic zealots, who also brutally assaulted his wife, killed him outside a book fair on the streets of Dhaka. Yet these fanatics have achieved the opposite of what they ultimately wished for: obliterating Avijit forever. Now, Avijit will leave a lasting legacy.
In fact, the name Avijit Roy is now synonymous with reason, science, and courage. This is accurate: for Avijit, it was important that the world know Bangladesh not simply as a struggling Muslim-majority country, but as a secular and free land where people could think independently and celebrate critical, evidence-based thinking. And he was willing to speak out in the face of death threats to spread this truth.
Avijit was a dear friend of mine. We first began communicating in 2000, when I was new to the Internet and searching for information about religion and secularism. I found Avijit among a handful of Bangladeshi writers debating Islamists on an Internet forum called News From Bangladesh. We immediately connected. At that time, we did not have our own website — although Avijit did have a personal page, where he gathered the translated writings of Aroj Ali Matubbor, a self-made Bangladeshi philosopher.
Then, in May 2001, Avijit formed a Yahoo group titled Mukto-Mona, which translates to “free mind.” It was meant to bring together people like us: secularists, rationalists, and atheists of Bangladeshi origin. We debated issues related to human rights, secularism, humanism, and the impact of religious doctrines — especially Islam and Hinduism — on politics in Bangladesh and other South Asian countries, including India and Pakistan.
Initially, this group consisted of a dozen people from Bangladesh. We were soon joined by people in India and Pakistan. Eventually, we felt the need for a website of our own. With web hosting help from Alan Levin, a humanist from Canada, Mukto-Mona was born as an online platform in 2002.
Within a few years of its formation, Mukto-Mona began to draw the attention of secularists, rationalists, and atheists not just inside and nearby, but also outside of Bangladesh. Its contributors would include Professor Humayun Azad, a Bangladeshi iconoclast — who, much like Avijit, was also brutally assaulted in a similar fashion in 2004. It also drew praises of such globally known names as Ibn Warraq, Taslima Nasrin, Victor Stenger, Austin Dacey, and the late Paul Kurtz.
In time, we also initiated the first Bangla celebration of Darwin Day, Rationalist Day, and International Women’s Day on the Internet. On each occasion, we received dozens of thought provoking essays and articles related to the celebrations.
Darwin Day was especially significant for us. Although there was plenty of information on Darwin and his theories in English, on the Internet there was almost no information on Darwin for a Bangla reader. As in many other parts of the world, misconceptions about Darwin and his theories abound in Bangladesh. Mukto-Mona filled this void and broke down those misconceptions. In fact, one of the first comprehensive Bangla books on the history and scientific basis of evolution was written by Bonna Ahmed, Avijit's wife.
But Mukto-mona was more than just a blog. We also worked on a number of social issues, from undertaking humanitarian projects, to speaking out against the repression and killings of religious minorities and secular writers and activists in Bangladesh, India, and Pakistan.
We even joined with formal organizations, including the International Humanist and Ethical Union and Rationalists International to organize protests against the arrest of Dr. Yunus Shaikh in Pakistan. Similarly, we raised our voice against the arrest of journalist Shahriar Kabir in Bangladesh, and condemned the killing of Muslims in Gujrat, India, and the atrocities committed against the minority Hindus in Bangladesh.
It is not an understatement to say that advent of Mukto-Mona on the Internet was monumental, both historically and culturally. Until then, there were no platforms for freethinkers of Bangladeshi origin — especially those who came out of Muslim backgrounds — to discuss and exchange opinions about topics such as the existence of God, the claims of religious scriptures and leaders, or LGBT issues. These are taboo topics for most Muslims in Bangladesh.
When I came into contact with Avijit, I was new not only to the Internet, but to the United States. Philosophically, I was going through a major transition. I grew up a pious Muslim, but had started to lose faith in organized religion. The beliefs which I held dearly for years began to disappear into the thin air, right before my eyes. And it was a hard topic to talk about with friends or family. If a Muslim friend or relative knew that I was questioning the existence of God (Allah), they would jump to the conclusion that I had been brainwashed, or must have been proselytized to another religion.
I vividly remember how thrilled I was when I discovered the websites for the Center for Inquiry and its programs, the Committee for Skeptical Inquiry, and Council for Secular Humanism. What a major sigh of relief it was to learn that I was not alone in asking questions about religions and scriptures — and that, in fact, at least one-fifth of the world population didn’t believe in any religion! The Internet opened a new world before me, an ocean of information on topics in which I was interested.
And, in particular, I was glad to have met Avijit. Although we came from different religious backgrounds, I found quite a few things in common with Avijit, culturally and ideologically. We exchanged opinions on a regular basis. Years later we would finally meet in person. He was rather shy and soft-spoken, and did not look exceptionally imposing. But he was as brilliant as I had come to expect.
Avijit was a prolific writer. “An engineer by training and a writer by passion,” is how he described himself on his Facebook page. And that passion ran deep.
Avijit authored four books, coauthored five books, and wrote countless articles. The uniqueness of his writings lies not just in the challenging topics he addressed — Avijit published many heretical articles debunking popular Islamic and Hindu myths, and refuting misconceptions about biological evolution, the origin of the universe, and homosexuality — but also in that almost never before had anyone written such enriched and well-researched information in Bangla. With his beautiful Bangla prose and penetrating analytical ability, Avijit received enthusiastic responses to his articles.
But Avijit was not only a writer; he was also a successful organizer and supporter of others. Mukto-Mona became the largest and the fastest growing group of contemporary freethinkers in Bangladesh and within South Asia, leading to many collaborative initiatives.
Moreover, a group of talented, spirited young writers have emerged around the Mukto-Mona who have learned to think outside the box, and not to allow doctrines, social or religious, to dictate their sense of good and bad. Rather, they are guided by reason, science, and humanist values. Over the past few years, many such freethinkers have even become published writers.
Avijit was at heart a staunch supporter of the right of people to speak out freely and fearlessly. When Islamic extremists attacked bloggers in Bangladesh for writing critically about Islam and its prophet Muhammad, Avijit spoke out in national and international arenas when. One of these bloggers, Ahmed Rajib Haider, was murdered in 2013. That same year, in an attempt to appease Islamists’ demands, the so-called secular government of Bangladesh would jail seven atheist bloggers. Avijit responded by touching base with his contacts at the Center for Inquiry and the International Humanist and Ethical Union to coordinate protests and political advocacy both nationally and internationally. Due to the widespread pressure, the Bangladeshi government would eventually release the jailed bloggers.
Such was Avijit Roy — an undaunted advocate of the secular and scientific outlooks, and of equal rights for all.
Like anyone, Avijit was not flawless. At times, Mukto-mona got bogged down in discussions that sounded more like preaching to the converted than promoting freethought. But we all have flaws, and Avijit was still special.
So, what’s Avijit’s most important legacy? I cannot help pondering.
In my opinion, it is that he transformed many minds, both young and adult, toward freedom, toward the courage to question convention, authority, tradition the “sacred” — toward a world free from all kinds of shackles and superstitions. Indeed, as Avijit described Mukto-Mona’s mission in 2007:
“… to build a society which will not be bound by the dictates of arbitrary authority, comfortable superstition, stifling tradition, or suffocating orthodoxy but would rather be based on reason, compassion, humanity, equality and science.”
That mission will live on as a legacy in the others who found him through it. As summarized by a Bengali Avijit fan posted on social media after his killing:
“He was Richard Dawkins of Bangladesh. …Today I know what is the philosophy of science, what is evolution, what is freethinking, what is logic. Today I can dare to dream of writing popular science in my mother tongue only because of him. He was a true master of modern thinking and writing. He, literally, was and is a hero of mine and, for sure, of many youngsters.”
What else could a man wish for as a legacy?
Jahed Ahmed lives in New York and may be reached at email@example.com. He is the author of the widely popular essay “My Experience with Islam” and a co-founder of the Mukto-Mona.com.
#1 Shabbir Ahmed (Guest) on Thursday March 12, 2015 at 10:17pm
Thanks Jahed Ahmed for writing Avijit Roy’s dedication and pioneering role for promoting free thinking through Mukto-Mona. Thanks also for providing a genesis of Mukto-Mona and its achievements in promoting free-thought among the young generation in Bangladesh. In particular, Dr. Avijit Roy was so eager to create a space for Bengali speaking freethinkers that he took his time and gave effort to create Bengali blog under Mukto-Mona. He also wrote a number of books in Bengali. Certainly, his legacy will live on with the Mukto-Mona freethinkers.
#2 Archie Bushee (Guest) on Friday March 13, 2015 at 4:56pm
I’m so sorry for the loss of such a wonderful man. I will do my best to help share his story.
#3 Sukhamaya (Sam) Bain on Friday March 13, 2015 at 7:35pm
Thank you, Jahed, for a very informative and enlightening article. Avijit was a significant player in the right side of where humans ought to be, humanity and rationalism; and his legacy will live on naturally. The aberration of the blind faith will surely die down. We just hope that humans would not suffer too much and for too long due to the senselessness and hatred of religious divisions.
It is indeed very unfortunate that we have lost a great soul so prematurely. Avijit had all the potential for contributing enormously for the cause of humanity. The fanatics of Bangladesh have killed a great son of Bangladesh.
#4 kousik bose (Guest) on Sunday March 15, 2015 at 2:31pm
I never realised we are still producing revolutionary philosophers among us. I am sure Avijit Roy’s name will be written in the same sentence as Rabindranath Tagore, Ram Mohan Roy and others great personalities in the future.
#5 Sankar Ray (Guest) on Wednesday March 18, 2015 at 7:19pm
I agree with every word and punctuation with you, Javed. Avijit will remain close to our heart and mind. You,Avijit and others have made mukto-mona.com a never-failing weapon of inspiration who believe in free-wheeling exchange of views, ethically committed to malice against malice.
#6 Bill Cooke (Guest) on Thursday March 19, 2015 at 11:00am
It’s so good to hear that Avijit Roy has not been forgotten, and that his work will carry on, despite the dangers posed by cowardly fanatics who resort to murder when they can’t win the argument any other way. It’s also good to hear that he translated the works of Aroj Ali Matubbor, whose works deserve to be better known.
#7 Bhaskar (Guest) on Thursday March 19, 2015 at 10:43pm
Avijit was today’s Socrates of Bangladesh.