Borneo’s Lake Monster Photos: Legend Come to Life? Or Hoax?

February 19, 2009

Two recently released photographs of a huge snake-like creature allegedly taken in Borneo is causing locals to wonder if a local legend may have come alive. One photo, of a serpentine shape in the Baleh river, was taken from a helicopter by a member of a disaster team monitoring flood conditions. The   Daily Mail (UK) published a story that began:

According to legend, the Nabau was a terrifying snake more than 100ft in length and with a dragon’s head and seven nostrils. But now local villagers living along the Baleh river in Borneo believe the mythical creature has returned after a photo of a gigantic snake swimming along the remote waterways has emerged. The picture,  taken by a member of a disaster team monitoring flood regions by helicopter, has sparked a huge debate about whether the photos are genuine or merely the work of photo-editing software. Even the respected New Straits Times newspaper in Kuala Lumpur has asked readers to make up their own minds about the photos. Villagers who claim to have seen the snake say they have given it the name of Nabau, after an ancient sea serpent which can transform itself into the shapes of different animals. People who have studied the photograph of the shape taken from the air have dismissed suggestions that it’s a log.

As a longtime lake monster expert (and co-author, with Joe Nickell, of Lake Monster Mysteries), I was asked by LiveScience.com to review the photos. The first thing I noted was the immediate link made to local folklore. Linking modern photographs and eyewitness reports to native stories and legends is a common mistake among cryptozoologists—those who look for evidence of mysterious or unknown creatures such as Bigfoot or lake monsters. But legends and myths may not have any connection to real events. Just because a native culture has a name for a strange monster or creature doesn’t mean that the beast ever actually existed. Fairies, dragons, and leprechauns populate our modern storybooks and legends, but we don’t assume they are real.

One of the first red flags to go up when considering any extraordinary photograph offered as evidence (of UFOs, Bigfoot, or lake monsters, for example) is an image submitted anonymously. The photographs were taken by an unnamed "member of a disaster team," at an unknown location and date. Two photos were released; one was taken from a helicopter, the second one wasn’t, suggesting that the creature was sighted on two separate occasions. That raises the question as to why there are only two photos; one might expect that a person seeing such an extraordinary creature might snap more than one picture each time.

 Readers can find my full analysis at http://www.livescience.com/strangenews/090219-borneo-monster.html.

 

Comments:

#1 Tony (Guest) on Thursday February 19, 2009 at 7:44pm

First of all a snake of that size would need to eat a huge meal in order to survive!
But then again the animal world does shock us into reality from time to time!

The Jungles hold Great Mysteries and Wonders just like the Oceans of the Deep!  Soon they will find Huge spiders the size of Dogs or cows there in the Jungles!
Anything is very possible!

#2 John (Guest) on Friday February 20, 2009 at 11:23am

They do have cows in the jungles of Indonesia. That’s where they originated and the only place on earth where wild cows still exist

#3 John Smith (Guest) on Saturday February 21, 2009 at 1:51pm

Here’s the river before it was photoshopped

#4 Ben Radford on Sunday February 22, 2009 at 2:23pm

John Smith—Thanks for finding that… looks more like the Congo to me!

#5 Septian (Guest) on Tuesday March 03, 2009 at 7:11pm

I that’s hoax…
none of that kind of thing exist..

#6 Anime (Guest) on Tuesday March 03, 2009 at 7:12pm

Mee to..none of that kin of thing ever exist..
just a legend..

Commenting is not available in this weblog entry.