Bounce God (and Fred Flintstone) from the Ballpark
April 17, 2009
“Take me out to the…God rally?”
When Bradford Campeau-Laurion was given the bum’s rush from Yankee Stadium last August for trying to leave the stands during the singing of God Bless America , the off-duty cop working the game who escorted him out told him he could leave the country if he didn’t like it. (This according to Campeau-Laurion’s federal lawsuit against the Yankees.)
The cops say Campeau-Laurion was using inappropriate language, was disorderly, and reeked of alcohol.
(Hmmm…I’m just picturing how many double-decker buses it would take to clear Yankee Stadium of everyone who used inappropriate language, was disorderly, and reeked of alcohol… )
But Campeau-Laurion says he got tossed because of when he was trying to leave the stands. He says the Yankees blocked some of the exits during the Irving Berlin song because it is disrespectful (unpatriotic?) to relieve oneself during this number. (Berlin, incidentally, did not believe in God, according to his daughter .)
So let me see if I have this straight. A guy gets up to leave as the crowd sings God Bless America , and he is forcibly removed to the street for not getting teary-eyed with the other folks in his section? There is so much wrong with that I hardly know where to start.
George Steinbrenner, the NYPD, the government of the United States - no one - can force you to like or respect God, this country, or anything in it. They can’t make you sing about it, hold your hand over your heart for it, or remove your cap as a sign of respect. Part of America being the land of the free entails being free to think for yourself.
Now I happen to love America. I am an American through and through. I’ve been to lots of other countries on 5 of the 7 continents and I feel lucky to have been born here, but you can’t compel me to be patriotic or God-fearing. On the contrary, my love for this country arises from the freedom it gives me to be an open atheist and to be uncomfortable with massive Nuremburg-style demonstrations of patriotism at the ballpark.
By the way, why is this even an issue at a goddamn ball game? Since when did patriotism or religiosity become a litmus test for being a fan at an athletic contest? Don’t we have a game to watch?
If you want to get all whipped up about something, make it your team . The stands in a ball park or stadium are perfect places to light fires under your loyalties… and prejudices. But the loyalties and prejudices should involve your team vs. the other team. It might involve calling a Green Bay fan a cheesehead at a Bears game in Soldier Field - or a White Sox fan calling Sammy Sosa "Corky" after he was caught with a cork-filled bat in 2003. That’s part of the sports landscape. And that’s the kind of partisanship that belongs at a game, not lining people up for God and Uncle Sam.
Anyone who buys a ticket and behaves himself reasonably well at a game should be able to stay ‘til the end without being molested by the management or the state - regardless of his or her beliefs or politics.
For me, saying God bless America means about as much as saying Fred Flintstone bless America. It makes no sense and it’s got nothing to do with baseball.
Oh for a little "Take me out to the ball game…"
#1 Personal Failure (Guest) on Friday April 17, 2009 at 11:32am
That is so ridiculous, just for practical reasons. What if the poor guy suffered from a prostate disorder that made him have to urinate a lot? Or a kidney disorder? What if he had a bladder infection (aka peeing every 1.5 minutes), but wanted to enjoy the game as much as he could anyway?
There are so many reasons this man could have had for needing to use the restroom during the song, that the cop had no way of knowing, that this is just abusive.
And seriously stupid.
Full disclosure and complete overshare: nerve damage has left me unable to feel the urge to urinate until it is a dire emergency, so this could happen to me quite easily. Once I realize that I have to go, I really, REALLY have to go. That could have been me desperate to use the restroom at what someone else might consider an inappropriate moment.
#2 gray1 on Friday April 17, 2009 at 7:59pm
Most conflicts result from over reactions to some stimulus or another. And so the cycle(s) continue.
BTW, “God Bless America” is a nice song, but it is not the national anthem. Perhaps “The Star Spangled Banner” was not available? If not, why not?
#3 Matt Marshall (Guest) on Sunday April 19, 2009 at 8:57pm
gray1—The National Anthem was certainly played, as always, before the game started. “God Bless America” would then have been played during the seventh-inning stretch. This tradition was started as part of the knee-jerk patriotism that flooded the land after 9/11—when baseball returned on 9/18/01, “GBA” was being sung in every ballpark. The Yankees continue to play it at every game to this day, while other teams might just play it now on Sundays and holidays.
You might ask why playing and celebrating our national pastime (and singing the national anthem) after 9/11 wasn’t patriotic enough. The answer, of course, is that neither of those things made it clear that the U.S.A. is God’s favorite country.
But, really, why do we even sing the national anthem before baseball games and other sporting events? We don’t sing it before movies, plays, concerts, gallery openings or any other kind of entertainment event. It started during WWII (again, at baseball games) and obviously spread to other sports like a cancer. Not sure when the way-cool, fighter-jet flyovers were added. But certainly nothing says sportsmanship like the loud display of imperialistic might.