Is The ‘Real-Life Barbie’ a Media Myth?
May 14, 2012
Beautiful? Ugly? Scary? Photoshopped? The story sparked outrage, with many using Lukyanova as a horrific example of the pursuit of beauty gone awry, the sad consequence of a society in which girls are encouraged to view thin fashion models and Barbie dolls as ideals. Jezebel.com, for example, headlined a piece "Ukrainian Model Has Supposedly Barbified Herself Through Plastic Surgery," and offered an animated video depicting "the many supposed surgeries that 21-year-old Ukrainian model, musician, and astroplanner Valeria Lukyanova has undergone to turn herself into a living, breathing Barbie." Fox News ran a piece titled "Why the 'Living Barbie' is Dangerous" by a psychiatrist named Keith Ablow, in which he stated that Lukyanova's quest to become Barbie doll-like was "an iconic symbol of things to come," when "self-expression requires mimicry of others, even of inanimate objects or fictional characters." People like Lukyanova (are there other people like her?), this outraged psychiatrist warns, "cannot empathize with the suffering of others" and "are, therefore, capable of causing enormous pain in the world, possibly even enjoying it." Ablow even compares this "real-life Barbie" to despots like Hitler and warns that Holocaust is a logical consequence of this mentality. Indeed, Ablow claims, "We are losing ourselves. We must reclaim ourselves. Everything depends on it."
Weird--but is it true? There's very little sourced information about Lukyanova, and even less in English, so it's hard to know exactly what to make of her motives or actions, but a few things suggest that there's much less to this whole story than meets the eye. In my book Media Mythmakers: How Journalists, Activists, and Advertisers Mislead Us (Prometheus, 2003) I investigated many news stories very similar to this one--sensational headlines about seemingly outrageous behavior, often with more than a hint of moral outrage and indignance. Sometimes the stories were true, but more often they were mostly or entirely wrong. They were widely spread and repeated not because they were true but because they supported well-defined cultural scripts and narratives about how journalists and the public view the world. In this case, with the ongoing culture wars bashing Barbies and thin fashion models as threatening to the psychological wellbeing of girls and women, this story of a woman who had undergone multiple, radical operations to become like Barbie was a perfect example of the dangers of Barbie the the quest for beauty. But was the story too good to be true?
Contrary to countless headlines, there's no evidence that Lukyanova is actually trying to emulate the world's most popular doll. The word "Barbie" does not appear anywhere on Lukyanova's Web site nor in any of the available material attributed to her. Furthermore a Google search of images of Lukyanova reveals plenty of airbrushed, cheesecakey glamour shots (some more staged than others), but conspicuously absent are any photos of her with her supposed idol, Barbie. Surely if this aspiring model's claim to fame was centered around trying to achieve Barbie's supposedly idealized proportions, she would have taken at least one photo of her with the doll she's trying to look like.
So if Lukyanova didn't introduce the Barbie aspect to the story, who did? The answer is news outlets like ABC News, Jezebel.com and the Huffington Post-HuffPo asserting that a "newsreel" (actually an animated satire from Next Media Animation) suggested that Lukyanova got her look through surgery (and may have paid around $800,000 for the work). Some news outlets expressed skepticism about parts of the story (for example noting that some of Lukyanova's images appeared fake), but it seems that no journalists challenged the basic premise of the overall story.
In fact, not only is there no evidence that Lukyanova is actually trying to achieve Barbie's look or form, there's also no evidence that she has undergone any plastic surgery, either to look like Barbie or for any other reason. It's certainly possible, though there are no before-and-after photos or videos that you would expect to see for such a publicized, planned radical transformation. Surely any plastic surgeon would be eager to claim credit for such remarkable work. While some photos and videos do show Lukyanova to have an unusually small waist, others do not, and in any event unlike Barbie it is well within normal human range.
If you remove the main claim from this sensational story (one woman's desire and surgical quest to become a human Barbie), you're left with a story of a young model whose portfolio includes hundreds of photos, some of which have her looking almost inhumanly perfect. In today's world of routine commercial airbrushing this story wouldn't go far even on a slow news day.
So what happened? How did otherwise ordinary photos and handful of short videos of a young blonde turn into a story of a model who spent a fortune trying to become a human Barbie doll? How did the news media get hoaxed by this story? Part of it is surely that the story taps into credible, pre-existing journalistic narratives, with elements of a great story: sex, beauty, obsession, and mystery. The myth of the real-life Barbie has a ready-made audience and a convenient news hook for those who want to blast America's obsession with beauty.
Amid the outrage and concern expressed over Lukyanova's alleged body and Barbie obsession, many people found the story tragic, posting comments like "Makes me want to cry... That is just so sad on so many levels." Indeed it is-but only if it's true.
#1 THux on Tuesday May 15, 2012 at 7:34am
Hundreds of photos? Try 11000 photos: http://vk.com/photos4926666. I haven’t looked at them all, but the earliest show her looking quite different. Whether she want to look like Barbie or not however, I can’t say, didn’t find any pictures of her with a Barbie in my brief look-around at that page.
#2 Esser on Tuesday May 15, 2012 at 7:38am
Anyone who undergoes surgery to this extent has underlying problems. I am fortunate enough to have married such a woman, without the need of surgery. It is very difficult for her to find clothes that fit properly and comfortably. Like most woman she wishes that she looked the opposite, like a Tomboy. While she is an avid fitness person her figure comes naturally. One of her two daughters is the same.
#3 DocNick (Guest) on Tuesday May 15, 2012 at 2:59pm
Google translation from pic:
“About me write articles on different sites, representing, like a doll, which has made an appearance, thanks to plastic surgery. Said one, and all repeated. His opinion no one else. Nobody needs to go to my site and read my notes. I keep a diary for many years, and it describes my life. But it’s not interesting. Much more interesting is to slander a man than to dig into his records and find reliable information in order to lay down their own opinion. It is much easier to just agree with the gossipy, and repeat for the rest. Unfortunately this is a mistake most people. They take someone else’s opinion as the truth of the first instance.
No one mentioned that I was a singer of opera New Age, which has a wide vocal range and coloratura soprano. No one told me that I composer and has written more than 70 songs on the theme of spiritual development. No one told me that I develop spiritually and lead seminars and trainings on out of body travel, answer questions and help people understand themselves. No one said that my looks, it is hard work for many years and good genes. No one told me that I rawfoodist, do not drink, do not smoke, lead a healthy lifestyle, and I’m on the road to pranaedeniyu.
But why? the easiest way to slander and to me as a pacifier for the appearance of which is nothing. But thanks to them for a PR, thinking people, and I know what they are, will visit and conduct a private investigation. Benefit of information about me - the sea, so that even his sneer, they helped me. More people know about my teaching, my work and my ideas! Love and Light to you!”
Sounds like she may be a believer in woo, but not in plastic surgery.
#4 Benjamin Radford on Wednesday May 16, 2012 at 9:16pm
Thanks for the translation, Nick!
#5 Max (Guest) on Saturday May 19, 2012 at 2:58am
Cathie Jung (born 1937) is an American Victorian dress and corset enthusiast residing in Old Mystic, Connecticut, USA, who currently holds the Guinness World Record for the smallest waist on a living person. Jung, who is 1.65 m (5 ft 6 in) tall, has a waist that measures 38.1 cm (15 inches).
#6 Max (Guest) on Saturday May 19, 2012 at 2:46pm
She has a video on YouTube titled “Valeria Lukyanova barbie doll.”
In other videos, she admits to having breast implants, but denies having any other plastic surgeries. It’s pretty obvious she had work done on her nose and mouth, especially when you see her photos before the surgeries. Some people speculate that she actually had ribs removed to get her small waist, which would be rather extreme. She says that to obtain her ideal Barbie-like figure, a girl should eat a little raw food once a day, i.e. starve herself, which isn’t healthy either.
#7 WebsiteChecker (Guest) on Friday June 01, 2012 at 6:50am
In recent days, I am trying to understand it, and searched a lot from the internet.but I still can not find a reasonable one. This article gives a good description about it,and help me understand the issue which confused me a lot.Thanks for your sharing! WebsiteChecker