Pakistani students turning away from Islam
September 6, 2010
One of the great ironies of the creation of Pakistan, a state whose very existence is defined by religion, Islam, is that the man considered the Father of the Nation, Muhammad Ali Jinnah, was an atheist. Before being forced into his role as defender of Muslim interests in 1930s still British India, Jinnah was a British trained lawyer, given to wearing Savile Row double-breasted suits, and who loved his whiskey, and is even said to have eaten pork. At any rate, Jinnah favored a secular constitution as was evident from the very last major speech that he gave just before his death in 1948.
My father and his generation of Pakistanis were agnostics, or at least secular. The British political commentator, socialist, journalist and novelist of Pakistani origin, Tariq Ali, who was born in 1943, confirms my experience. Ali wrote, “I never believed in God, not even between the ages of six and ten, when I was an agnostic....My parents, too, were non-believers. So were most of their close friends. Religion played a tiny part in our Lahore household. In the second half of the last century, a large proportion of educated Muslims had embraced modernity.” The later turn to Islamic fundamentalism of Pakistan in the 1970s, inaugurated by dictator, Zia-ul Haq, was well-satirised by Hanif Kureishi in his marvellous screenplay for the Stephen Frears film, “My Beautiful Launderette”; two brothers of Pakistani origin in their fifties are talking about going back to the old country, but one brother stops short this wild train of thought by saying, “The old country [Pakistan] has been sodomized by religion”.
Yesterday, I read a story that cheered me up considerably. New Delhi Television on line published a story on September 5, 2010 about Pakistani youth giving up religion. A Facebook group has been created for Pakistan's agnostics and atheists by former Pakistani Muslim, Hazrat NaKhuda [obviously a pseudonym- the adopted surname means “no God”.] There are now 100 members. Hazrat, a computer programmer from Lahore, writes, "I used to be a practicing Muslim. I used to live in Saudi Arabia. I have done two Hajs and countless Umrahs. Used to pray five times a day. When I turned 17-18, I realized that the only reason I was a Muslim was because my parents were Muslims". Another member, Ahmad Zaidi, wrote, "I'm an agnostic simply because I see little or no evidence for the existence of God. Some time ago I decided that I'd never believe anything unless it has a firm basis in reason and as far as I know (and I admit I know very little and that there's much to be learnt), there's little or no evidence for the existence of God."
The members of the group are
students, some studying abroad, but many are at the Lahore
University of Management Sciences. One student, Nawab Zia, says we
should ask not “how we became atheists” but “how we became
believers”. He wrote, "I was a born atheist like every human
being until my parents corrupted me with faith. Every child is born
free and pure”. Ali Rana, who loved Islamic preacher Zakir
Nair and hated author Salman Rushdie, has had a change of heart too.
He now thinks Nair is an "idiot" and Rushdie a genius. Many
members describe on the discussion boards how they “wasted” their
years as theists.
What that famous ex-Communist, Arthur Koestler, said about communism applies also to ex-Muslims: “You hate our Cassandra cries and resent us as allies, but when all is said, we ex-Communists are the only people on your side who know what it's all about”.
#1 Bala (Guest) on Monday September 06, 2010 at 8:15am
Pakistan is one country that desperately needs a generous helping of reason and sanity. Stories like these and bloggers like Dawn’s Nadeem Parcha are what gives me hope that my neighboring country will pick itself up and progress.
p.s. - it’s Zakir NaiK, not naiR.
#2 liberalartist on Monday September 06, 2010 at 3:55pm
This gives one hope for the future. For every atheist in an Islamic county that speaks out, how many more are there still afraid to speak out. Perhaps more than we think.
#3 John Kelly (Guest) on Thursday September 09, 2010 at 11:16am
When we think of problems people in the US experience when we make our atheism public it is unimaginable the danger a Pakistani must experience in Pakistan. Bravery is a term that fits them well.
What of us in the US. I know of people who still attend church only for reasons unrelated to belief in god. They do it because their children would be ostracized, their livelihood would be threatened, their friends would abandon them if they didn’t. Church represents a path for social climbing, a feeling of community, an path for charitable giving. Publicly acknowledging atheism could be a hardship but not a threat to life and limb.
Maybe what we need here is to make contact with atheists from the Islamic countries and have them speak at what meetings we have.