The Bible Was Written by Drunkards and Junkies
May 5, 2010
Well, maybe -- but that's not the point. Rather, the point is Polish pop star has been charged in her home country for stating just that, under a law that protects the feelings of religious believers in the heavily Roman Catholic country. Dorota Rabczewska, 26, otherwise known as Doda, faces two years in jail or a hefty fine for stating that The Bible is full of "unbelievable tales" that are hard to accept because:
"... it's hard to believe in something written down by someone drunk on wine and smoking some kind of herbs."
Polish law dictates that such charges are brought only if at least two complaints are filed. Doda’s statements apparently riled the religious sentiments of a sufficient number of Catholics, who successfully pressured the Polish government to press charges against the singer. Said Ryszard Nowak, chairman of the Committee for the Defence Against Sects, an organization dedicated to protecting Christian values:
"It is clear that Doda thinks that the Bible was written by drunkards and junkies. I believe that she committed a crime and offended the religious feelings of both Christians and Jews."
But it doesn't matter whether Doda hurt peoples' feelings by stating The Bible was written by men who drank too much wine and did drugs . Free speech includes the right to offend, for peoples' subjective feelings form an incoherent and abitrary basis for lawmaking. Governments surely have an interest in punishing certain public speech that might provoke hatred of or violence against people , but they should not protect beliefs and ideas from critique. Blasphemy laws like the one in Poland needlessly restrict liberty, preventing members of society from freely speaking their minds and examining reigning beliefs and values. As CFI President and CEO Ron Lindsay has said:
“Preserving the right to uncensored expression is important not only because it is indispensable for an objective examination of truth claims—it is no accident that dictatorships uniformly suppress speech—but also because it has intrinsic value. Human dignity requires the freedom to express oneself as an individual.”
Oddly enough, Doda is engaged to the lead singer of the Polish death metal band Behemoth, Adam Darski, who is currently on trial for tearing up a Bible onstage at a concert in Poland in Sept. 2007. To be sure, Poland has never imprisoned someone for blasphemy, but those charged have faced lengthy trials, monetary fines, and/or other punishments like travel bans -- just for criticizing religious beliefs, ideas, values, and symbols (that's offensive to me ). Free speech advocates should fully support both Doda and Darski, and hope that ensuing public attention brings about enough of a groundswell to pressure Westernized governments to overturn these archaic speech-limiting laws and show support for free speech in the international arena.
#1 SimonSays on Wednesday May 05, 2010 at 3:11pm
The Catholic Church has a history of targeting heavy metal. Back in 1992 they managed to get a scheduled Iron Maiden concert canceled.
I’m not really certain I agree with your justification though. A proponent of holocaust denial would claim they too are espousing a belief and/or an idea. I’m not sure why it’s more ethical to imprison a holocaust denier than Doda. The only way to claim this is to assume that some ideas are inherently more dangerous than others and that lawmakers should decide what those ideas are with prison sentences to follow. I’m sorry but this is the definition of political imprisonment, regardless of how abhorrent or ignorant a particular view may be someone else.
Any government that makes holocaust denial (or any speech that isn’t a direct “call-to-violence”) a crime punishable by imprisonment, will no doubt make other similar “offenses” punishable in order to make political statements against other ideas it does not like. That is exactly what is going on here: Doda has made a statement the Polish government doesn’t like, so under pretty similar legal justification they’re now going after her.
#2 Michael De Dora on Wednesday May 05, 2010 at 3:22pm
Simon, I do not support Holocaust denial laws.
#3 L. Long (Guest) on Wednesday May 05, 2010 at 5:40pm
At least the buybull wasn’t written by stone-age desert goat pluckers.
#4 Michael De Dora on Wednesday May 05, 2010 at 6:04pm
By the way, I think Nowak blows out of proportion what Doda really said:
“... it’s hard to believe in something written down by someone drunk on wine and smoking some kind of herbs.”
To Nowak, that means drunkards (as in people who are habitually drunk) and junkies (as in addicted to smoking some kind of herbs).