A Question of Identity

June 6, 2010

A Question of Identity.

I have often addressed Iranian audiences without fear in several countries- Stockholm, Sweden; Paris, France; London, U.K.; and in Washington, D.C., Chicago, and Los Angeles. The Iranians attending were either atheists, agnostics, secularists, and Zoroastrians. The first language my first book, Why I am not a Muslim, was translated into was Persian, or Farsi by an agnostic Iranian. On one occasion at a lecture that I gave to some Iranians, the Iranian organizer of the event wondered why it was that the first thing that newly arrived Pakistani students looked for was where they could procure halal/ kosher chicken and meat, whereas what the Iranian students celebrated was their newly found freedom.

Most Pakistanis are historically, ethnically, and in fact in many ways culturally, related to Indians. And yet, Pakistanis are taught more about the [mythical] history of Arabs than about the magnificent, and rich history of the Sub-continent of India. Many Pakistanis will even boast of their descent from the "Arabs" who periodically devastated India, and some even of their descent from the family of the Prophet, Muhammad. The Pakistanis are also schooled in contempt for all things Indian- an artificial, fanatical nationalism is whipped up by the politicians and turned against their neighbour, which has led to several wars-three major wars, one minor war, and countless armed skirmishes- since Independence. When will the Pakistanis learn to treat Indians as brothers and sisters? When will they learn that their future lies with a rapprochement with India, and not the Arabian peninsula?

Pakistan was created only sixty three years ago, and the raison d'etre was religion. If you take away religion, Islam, from them, Pakistanis are lost, and hence when they leave Pakistan they have to cling to this religious identity in an environment which they have been taught to despise. Iranians, on the other hand, can boast of one of the oldest civilizations in the World, pre-dating Islam, of course. They do not feel culturally lost without Islam, they even celebrate pre-Islamic Zoroastrian festivals such as Nowruz, the New Day. Iranians are secure in their identity, even without Islam. The greatest number of freethinkers are to be found in Iranian communities outside Iran, hence their frequent invitations to me.


#1 kafir on Monday June 07, 2010 at 4:55am

One more example of Pakistanis’ Arabphile is they have switched to saying ‘Allah Hafiz’ instead of centuries old term of ‘Khuda Hafiz’,which is ofcourse of persian origin! Though most Indians, including polytheist Hindus love to use the second term.
Zoroastrians had fled to India from Iran due to religious prosecution and became part of Indian fabric.We address their community as ‘Parsis’, a distortion of Farsi(Persian).They are one of the most successful and respectable minority community of India.

#2 Ophelia Benson on Monday June 07, 2010 at 10:23am

I’ve always wondered about that. Until Partition the people who are now “Pakistanis” were Indians, then all in a moment they weren’t, and now they hate Indians with a white-hot passion. It seems so tragic, so alienating, so sad.

#3 Universalgeni (Guest) on Saturday June 26, 2010 at 2:28am

Ibn Warraq: What is the matter with you guys? You run quite a bit site but there’s no search function here? No list with the blogs you host at this site? No new videos for almost a year?

Please say that you intent to video tape the conference this year in Amherst, NY July 23, 2010?

And get your house in order. Search function and a local blogroll, thank you! How can we participate in the fight against islamism when we can’t find things. Really! :-(

Commenting is not available in this weblog entry.