Something to Fear?

March 21, 2011

The weekend edition of The Wall Street Journal summarized two academic studies that may be of interest to some in the freethought community.

One study concluded that there were discernible geographic patterns in the distribution of fear regarding various events, with southern European countries registering the highest fear levels and countries such as Finland, Austria, and The Netherlands the lowest. Significantly, the “most robust determinant of a nation’s fear factor was the proportion of citizens who believe in hell.” So the lesson is: Scare them once and they stay scared.

On the other hand, a separate study delivered some news that might concern those of us skeptical of hell and other supernatural phenomena. This other study concluded, “If there is a genetic component to religious belief, the pro-religion variant is mathematically bound to win out … if believers continue to outbreed nonbelievers.” The study factored in defection rates, that, is the rate of believers who leave their religion, and even a 50% defection rate is not sufficient to prevent the religious allele from spreading through the population after 20 generations.

OK, the breeding part is probably a given. There are many groups like the Mormons on one side versus notoriously low-breeding atheists on the other. But there are still a lot of “ifs” associated with this study. That there is a set of genes associated with religious belief remains very much uncertain. Moreover, as we all know, having a gene that predisposes one to certain behavior does not necessarily result in that behavior occurring. Genotype is not the same as phenotype. Various factors can prevent a gene from influencing conduct. Perhaps all we need to suppress the religious allele is a healthy dose of reality.



#1 ALF (Guest) on Friday March 25, 2011 at 2:32am

I bear the surname of the largest known known non-violent terrorist front in the U.S.A., that is known for its “direct actions”.
Does that mean Fear has Rules.
As a conciouss Christian, taught in my religous world, that there are limited resources here on Earth, and for those who want the living/life to continue well they can learn. Procreation is not thee as a result of creation, if the voice inside your head says this perceived world is not worth living in. As an Anarchist, am I an anti-christ, or a bright torch passed on by the spirit. Didn’t eating an apple create this discussion, that is between good and evil right, so what is behind your fig leaf. Reality would dictate, “We we’re, we are, we will be” when the fact that our actions have results we can perceive.Are you afraid of yourself or others when fear is distilled into reality. Questions? Can you make holywater by boiling the Hell out of it? Are you Sacred, Scared, or skared, and is it not just a missed spelling?

Commenting is not available in this weblog entry.